.

Canton EDA Member Resigns

Andrew Charron’s decision, controversy over suggested appointment the latest in tension between agency and some selectmen.

A member of the Economic Development Agency resigned last week, citing interactions with the Board of Selectmen as his main reason.

Andrew Charron was out of town Wednesday but asked agency colleagues to read a letter on his behalf.

Charron said the agency had made great strides toward helping the town improve its tax base while retaining "small town virtues," declare Canton "open for business," bring relief to residents and fund "needed capital improvements proejct such as the pool and track projects. These go hand in hand with attracting more business and economic growth." 

In his letter, Charron cited many actions by selectmen he thought inappropriate, most recently a recent e-mail from selectman Steve Roberto hat he called an attack on the Economic Development Agency.

In the e-mail Roberto responded to a proposal from EDA chairman Kevin Jackson supporting resident Chris Budnick, who had applied to serve on the agency.

In part, Roberto questioned Jackson’s use of the word “we” in an e-mail supporting Budnick. Roberto asked how the agency had come to a consensus on that and many other issues this summer when it hadn’t met in months.

“You have made several public comments recently about how the EDA has been discussing certain issues and endorse or oppose certain things. They seem to be meeting somewhere at sometime. Perhaps if your committee members are unavailable for a regular meeting you can schedule a special meeting to make your business open and available to the general public,” Roberto wrote.

Selectmen Tom Sevigny replied and said he felt the accusations were “inflammatory.” He said proof should be offered if someone felt they were holding secret meetings and said the issue should be discussed in an open meeting, not via e-mail.

Roberto also wrote that he appreciated Budnick’s willingness to serve but felt the EDA could use some diversification, perhaps a long-time resident who owned a “small to medium brick and mortar business.”At Wednesday’s meeting, the issue of Budnick’s appointment came up again.

Jackson said the agency has missed four meetings due to lack of a quorum and touted Budnick and his background as an U.S. Army officer and businessman.

"He is energetic, enthusiastic and anxious to serve our community,” Jackson said.

Jackson asked the board to add the appointment to its agenda.

"We have him courteously appearing, expecting to be appointed tonight,” Jackson said.

From there Sevigny motioned to add it. 

With no resume or information in the front of him Selectman David Gilchrist Jr. said he felt he lacked information.

“I don’t have enough information to make a decision,” Gilchrist said.

Sevigny said appointments are routinely made with only an application and resume.

First Selectman Richard Barlow said he had told Jackson it would not be on the agenda until the next Board of Selectmen meeting. He later said the agency should have one Democrat on its roster.

Jackson responded, "With all due respect Dick we had about two years to fill position and now all of sudden we bring someone to the table that is eminently qualified for this position and there’s a whole hullabaloo that will be addressed in the next public comment. There’s a great deal of grief around this and this absolutely no reason that a qualified in candidate like this who is first in line to take a position should be considered.”

EDA member Glenn Arnold also expressed similar thoughts and emphatically said the EDA has not had any meetings outside of the public forum.

The board then voted on adding the item to the agenda, which failed 2-2, with Sevigny and Lowell Humphrey voting for it and Gilchrist and Barlow against. (Roberto was not yet at the meeting due to another commitment).

At the end of the meeting selectmen addressed the issues again.

Roberto said he felt his comments were blown out of proportion and referenced Charron’s allegations the he accused the EDA of being unfriendly to small business and that he wanted a “passive EDA.”

“I’m looking for an EDA that wants to work with the Board of Selectmen that doesn’t become personally offended when others want to offer thought or actions or strategies to be considered,” Roberto said. “It seems like every time I utter the words EDA someone’s feelings are hurt.”

Although Budnick lives in a different area of town and has lived here for 12 years, Roberto did reference the current membership of the EDA, pointing out that they are four individuals in the same “neighborhood," all roughly the same age and less than 10 years in town.

“Now there’s nothing wrong with that but the fact is I don’t see any problem with suggesting that we round out a board or commission with somebody that has decades in town and has personal property and business interests in town,” Roberto said. “My comment was that the commission lacked that perspective. It’s a fact and I think that perspective would be helpful.”

He also pointed to Charron’s letter that states with regard to the projects going to the ballot in November. Charron accused selectmen of holding the roads hostage by bundling them with the garage and proceeded to question the price of the garage, writing, “It was then disappointed to hear certain members voted against a track and field project on the basis of fiscal responsibility but not two minutes before approved what we all know is a huge cost for a public works garage.”

Roberto said he has heard the EDA make those statements but said they had offered no data, a better site or shown how it could be done less expensively.

Barlow, a Republican, called the EDA “pretty much a one-party agency" with one unaffiliated and three Republican members. He said the board should be bipartisan.

“I have been reaching out to Democrats in town and finally procured one that is willing to serve and possibly another one,” Barlow said. “It’s my intention to bring that individual to the board at the next meeting for your consideration.”

Still Humphrey felt Budnick was treated “fairly shabbily” and at deserved at least a vote.

Barlow said he had told Jackson it would not be on the agenda and said it was the chairman’s prerogative to still bring the individual to the meeting.

Sevigny said appointments are often done at the last minute and felt it a dangerous road to start looking for “various criteria” beyond political affiliation.

“For some reason Mr. Budnick’s application caused a stir," he said. “I don’t know why but it did.”

He said he did read Roberto’s comments as an attack but also said the EDA needs to realize that selectmen will sometimes go in different directions than they would like.

“I would like to see it dialed down on both sides,” he said. “We have a lot of important work to do on economic development and all that it encompasses over the next few years.”

Barlow said he felt the EDA has often been overly negative about the town.

As for as the word “we” being used several times this summer, Barlow said the problem might also be one of articulation.

“The only way any board and commission should be doing those kinds of things and saying we is if they do it in a formal, open forum,” Barlow said. “They need to understand a little bit more about the protocol and how they serve as an agency.”

Canton Taxpayer September 17, 2012 at 02:49 PM
Mr. Roberto is right -- where are the Agendas and Minutes of the EDA? It looks like due to a lack of quorum - with Andrew Charron being absent for even the most recent meeting in APRIL - there have been no meetings, so how has the EDA decided on any course of action, recommendation or suggestions? If Mr. Jackson means showing up at Selectmen meetings and saying he's for bonding the pool and track -- did the EDA decide to back those projects or did Mr. Jackson as a neighbor and citizen as he said during Selectmen meetings? As for rounding out the committee -- that just seems prudent and reasonable.
Betty September 17, 2012 at 04:28 PM
The town of Canton made great efforts to form a Plan of Conservation and Development Update Committee which was diverse and balanced. I believe their diversity and balance is a huge contributing factor in their success and will produce the best result for all of Canton. Why would we not strive for the same diversity in our Economic Development Agency? I am sorry to hear of Andrew Charron's resignation I think very highly of him. I agree with Canton Taxpayer having an entire committee from one neighborhood does not seem prudent. Canton would benefit from more diversity. Why would we not want to be more inclusive? Why would we not want diversity? Why would we not want someone with a historical point of view?
Wyatt September 17, 2012 at 04:34 PM
@Betty. Sounds like an argument for quotas and affirmative action. Your fellow liberals would be proud. 1. Membership should be based upon merit and expertise, not what neighborhood someone is from. 2. There should not be neighborhood quotas on town committees. 3. There is no evidence that the EDA is not being inclusive. Do you have any evidence to support such an allegation? 4. Do you have any evidence that the EDA does not want diversity? 5. Do you have any evidence that the EDA does not want someone with a "historical point of view?" What does that even mean? Sounds like you might be discriminating against newer residents and younger residents.
Canton Taxpayer September 17, 2012 at 05:22 PM
Problem there is -- they don't even bother to have public meetings or let the public know what they're doing as a "committee"....as for who they have on the committee -- 'historical point of view' would probably indicate someone who's been in town more than 10 years. That just seems well-rounded, not discriminatory.
N. Jon I. Twist November 27, 2012 at 03:20 PM
Do we need another with a military background, we were lucky to get rid of one on the Board of Selectmen. Betty's comment about the Plan of Conservation and Development Update Committee is right on. They had diversity and expertise. This group seems to have an AXE to grind!!!

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something